The Not So Legal Show

I had written a post about this guy, Compton Gardner, who erected a gate that prevented a bunch of his neighbors from accessing their property. I deleted the post because I didn’t really like it. However, someone read it and was asking what had happened. You will be happy to know that the judge ordered Mr. Gardner to take down the gate. This is one of those times where  you wish people would act rationally. I mean, is it really necessary to put up a gate to make a point! Neighborly disputes can be such an ordeal. Send me some comments on what you guys have had to deal with sometimes with your neighbors. I would be curious to hear about it. For those of you who missed the article that prompted my post, here it is:

Angry residents called Los Angeles authorities, who pledged that they would move quickly to resolve the dispute and have the gate removed from the street, which has been in use since 1924.

But the street remained blocked Wednesday morning when Freyre, 61, and her 30-year-old daughter, Norma Enriquez, squeezed past the gate to get to the car they had parked outside it overnight.

“This is unbelievable,” said Freyre, who was worried what would happen later in the day when her son planned to bring his prematurely born child home from the hospital for the first time.

She glanced past the gate to the quarter-mile walk that David Freyre would face while carrying the infant and his breathing monitor and oxygen tank.

The street standoff, on an isolated hillside above Lincoln High School and the busy intersection of North Broadway and North Mission Road, was causing ripples Wednesday three miles away at Los Angeles City Hall.

“This is a unique situation. I’ve never seen this level of animosity,” said City Councilman Ed Reyes, who represents Lincoln Heights. “It’s a tough situation. We’re trying to maintain public safety for all residents. It’s a delicate issue between residents’ rights.”

Reyes’ staff was scurrying to find temporary housing for 5-month-old Aiden Freyre and his father and mother, Ruth Shafer.

“That’s a priority. We’re working for housing so an ambulance could get to them easily,” Reyes said.

Back on Forest Park Drive, Compton was pleased that the city was taking notice of the situation.

“This is a little test of property rights,” he said . “It’s got everyone’s attention.”

Compton, 76, is an Emmy-winning TV producer and writer who through a trust owns 23 lots on what many locals call Paradise Hill.

He hopes to eventually build a solar-powered home on top that will have a view sweeping from the Hollywood sign to Mt. Baldy and Catalina Island.

“It will be my ‘paradise’ in case I don’t get to paradise,” he said with a laugh.

But his relationship has been rocky with some neighbors, Compton said.

“It’s been very bizarre. They filed 112 complaints with the city against me last year. I’ve been attacked physically, yelled at. I got a restraining order against one of them.”

Ilse Ackermann says she was the focus of the restraining order three years ago.

Ackermann and her husband, Meeno Peluce, a photographer, purchased their 1905-era house from Compton in 2002. For the last six years, they have rehabilitated the wood-frame dwelling and lushly landscaped its grounds.

Anthony Converse, a 43-year-old Echo Park musician who for 3 1/2 years has owned a pair of lots off Forest Park Drive where he intends to build a house, said the dispute has delayed development and caused him to forfeit an $80,000 construction loan.

“The absurdity of this is kind of hard to grasp,” Converse said.

He said he was particularly upset by a demand that he and other property owners on the street pay Compton and his trust $200,000 to “reimburse” and “compensate” them for their purported harassment of Compton over the last five years.

Disagreement over who should pay for street widening, paving and maintenance if new homes are allowed next to Forest Park Drive are at the center of the dispute. Compton wants everyone to share in the cost and in fees for formal right-of-way dedication to the city.

Residents have complained that the road was fine until unapproved grading done by Compton on the hill next to and above the road threatened its usefulness in rainy weather.

Over the last few days the dispute has drawn representatives of the city attorney and the building and safety offices to the gate, along with Fire Department officials and police.

Late Wednesday, Compton opened the gate so that Freyre and Shafer could drive Aiden home and agreed to give them a key to its lock in case they need to rush the baby back to the hospital. Firefighters will also get keys.

Police Officer Austin Fernald, the LAPD’s senior lead officer for the Lincoln Heights area, said he had been to the scene eight times in recent days.

“So far, there’s been no dispute, no physical altercation when I was there. Just frayed nerves,” Fernald said.

Reyes, meantime, said the city was weighing going to court today to seek a resolution to the street dispute.

Reyes believes that the law is on the residents’ side and that any court would find that a road that has been public for decades cannot revert to private use.

For his part, Compton said he plans to up the ante in the next few days.

“By this weekend, foot traffic will be blocked too. Side wings will be welded on both sides of the gate to prevent trespassing,” said Compton, adding that residents would still be able to use an old hillside trail and steep wooden steps to get from Broadway to their homes.

Meanwhile, the hillside dust-up might make for good television, the show-business veteran allowed.

“I’m thinking it would be a great TV show,” he said. “Not a reality show, a comedy show.”

Maybe he could name it after his trust — which Compton calls “Le Bout du Monde.”

“It means ‘the end of the world.’ Not cataclysmically, but the last crumb of cake on the platter,” he said.

Pool is a Times staff writer.